View Single Post
Old 09-10-2017, 11:25 AM   #105
Peter's Avatar
Join Date: Aug 2000
Location: UK
Posts: 9,604

Originally Posted by Quijote View Post
Yes, a real "wake-up" call!! We can imagine perhaps the shock that caused to congregations at the time. (Akin, to take a later example, to the opening of Beethoven's 1st symphony where he starts with a series of V7s outside of the expected key. These gestures strike us as unsurprising these days, but to the sensibilities of the Viennese audience at that time they must have also been quite a jolt.)

As to the opening chord of the BWV* 54, it's a naughty, incomplete II2, i.e. 117 in last inversion; naughty because any inversion of a seventh chord should be complete, as the textbooks tell us. But Bach operates to his own rules...

* I can't tell you how many times I tend to write BMW - is this a marque of car I subconsciously desire?
Isn't this unprecedented? I can't think of earlier examples in Bach or elsewhere that start a piece like this.
'Man know thyself'
Peter is offline